These are exactly what I was looking for! I did a ton of searching for months, needing a pair of chairs to put in what used to be a rarely used kitchen nook and these fill it beautifully! Its a wide space and my husband is quite large as well so the oversized dimensions were just what we needed.  The seat is quite firm but by no means would I consider it uncomfortable. There are some marks on one of the back cushions (picture here, but the color is super washed out, not at all what the blue looks like) which I have to assume is due to the packaging. The chairs come wrapped in plastic then have cardboard around the sides, however only the plastic covers the seat opening. The feet were super easy to put on and despite having plastic casters, I still added felt pads. Such a great deal!!!