I upgraded to this one because I wanted it to match the other fixtures in the bathroom and because the last TP holder I had kept coming out of the wall.  I had to re-install the thing multiple times.  While the quality is definitely there, I am not a big fan of the design.  The 2 piece configuration makes it more difficult to install.  If you don't get it exactly lined up, your toilet paper holder won't close properly.   I had to have my husband tape it up and hold it while I measured.  It remains to be seen whether or not this 2 piece configuration will hold up or start coming off the wall like the last one.