I’m giving this product four stars. The unboxing was easy enough, these rugs came in a nylon duffle which was a great presentation. Full disclosure they are made in China. Seemingly waterproof, there was a slight gas off when I unrolled them. They did not recurl after unrolling, having a substantial weight. The doormat seems to be of a standard expected size, the seems are tight and no foam is exposed on either piece. They are smooth although the top looks textured. I’m going with the four stars based on the quality of the texture imaging, with inconsistencies here and there. This might have been intended though, to make it look more like a realistic weave.