This mantle was exactly what we wanted for our refaced fireplace.  The stain is a rich, dark brown.  The pine is somewhat rustic with a few knots, but it isn't distressed or excessively rough.  The only negative is that it didn't come with a mounting cleat.  We were able to create one with a piece of wood that we had, but it would have been nice if one was included--especially since this item was not cheap.  Overall, we are very happy with our purchase.