I am giving three stars because these are "just ok." I know their pretty inexpensive so i expected some shortcuts - I guess I'm happy with the purchase for what it is. Here is what buyers should know with that in mind...the top down doesn't close back up snug to the mounted rail on top and always has about a 1/8"-1/4" gap on top no matter what I do. The cell shade pleats are very small, kind of busy, and cheap looking. The handle clips are tiny and really flimsy. If you have other cell shades in your home that you bought from a custom shade place these will be disappointing attributes. Its not horrible, just buyer beware. I knew these would be temporary so its fine with me!