The one star is based on the price.  The tray itself is ok.  It's exactly as pictured look wise, but it is flimsy and WAY overpriced for what you get.  If I had seen this in person, I would have paid $10-$15 tops!  I have an old boot tray from LL Bean that I paid the same amount as this for and it is so much more solid and sturdy.  Don't waste your money.