The island is great quality, especially for the price.  We needed something for a couple years until we completely renovate our kitchen and this island is perfect for that.  It took my husband and I less than 2 hours to assemble.  The directions were clear.  Overall, it's a nice island with lots of storage.  I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 as the leaf isn't super secure when up.  We keep it up all the time with bar chairs there.  My 4 old and I have eaten at it many times and it is strong enough for her to lean on, but I wouldn't lean on fully it myself.  Wayfair was great to work with and the delivery was on time. 

Pros: Easy assembly, nice finish, sturdy, reasonably priced
Cons: Only offered with wood countertop