I ordered 2 of these and one of them had a big gash in the leather.  Returned that one for a quick replacement, but now the leather on the two don't match exactly.  I like them and don't want to deal with more returns so I am keeping them and hoping the difference isn't noticeable to anyone other than myself.  They swivel nicely and are a great value for the price- especially compared to how pricey all other similar looking chairs are.