I am only giving a 3 star rating since I've been using this freezer less than a month.  While it has been working great so far, I am reserving a higher rating for when it makes it through a Texas summer in our garage.  
This freezer replaced a smaller GE freezer that died after only 4 years(and both are garage rated).  So I am cautiously optimistic that this one lasts.  Lots of room in this one, and it comes with 2 baskets which are nice.