These are nice, simple, functional trays -- we needed them to provide a flat surface on our tufted coffee table/ottoman, and I'm really happy with how they look and function there.  The stain on the two pieces was somewhat different, one was warmer and one was more grey, so I took a star off, but the wood grain patterning is attractive and I'm hoping the difference won't be so pronounced when the trays are in use.  I didn't appreciate the details of the little metal bracket on the corners, which is whimsical and pretty!