The great/good: Large capacity, easy to use, accurate burner/heat control.  The meh...: It took way to long to put together - this thing should have come at least somewhat pre-assembled.  It needs to have better covers to protect the flame from the wind blowing the flame out (granted, the wind here can be very strong).  You can pull out the water tray to refill while smoking but it spills all over when you move the water tray - the easier way to refill the water tray is to open the main door and pour down into the tray....but that means you have to open the main door.  Not a biggie as the burner catches back up fairly quickly but it still rates a meh....  The main door arrived with a fairly large dent on its edge.....I didn't complain about it because I can accept some issues when I purchase things to be delivered.