I am rating these a 3 due to the fact they are not made perfect.  They are beautiful dishes but be prepared to have to get a couple of sets just to get a complete good set.  I had a problem with one of my first two sets and yes, Wayfair did immediately send out another replacement set but only two dinner plates were not flawed.  I only needed two dinner plates and two salad plates to complete my set but I think it's ridiculous that only two plates out of four were good and none of the salad plates were perfect.  Again, I didn't let Wayfair know due to the fact I received what I needed replaced.  I'm just letting others aware that you may not get a perfect setting in one box, otherwise, I love the dishes.  They are nice but the workmanship needs major improvements.