We just received our dining set a week ago, but so far we are VERY impressed with the quality for the price. Everything arrived in good shape...no dings or damage. Assembly was pretty typical for this type of furniture...no major problems. The finish is very true to the on-screen images...dark brown with a hint of red. The table and chairs are very solid, not at all flimsy or rickety. Since these pieces are veneer over hardwood, it will take time to know how well the finish holds up. The set works perfectly in our breakfast area and we have received compliments from friends and family.