After a year or two of use, my plates are scratched up just from normal use.  There are only 3 of us in the house, all adult.  I had hoped that paying more. for quality would result in better wear.  I got this set to replace a more inexpensive one that was scratched and worn looking.  But i dont think these are wearing any better than. my cheap dishes did.  Too bad, because they are lightweight and elegant.