This does an excellent job of smelling nice and clean. Unfortunately, that is the sole strong point. It requires putting a lot of pressure on it to pick up dirt (more pressure than using a regular wash cloth) which brings us to the second problem: the pole bends to the point of almost breaking if you actually intend to do anything  more than slightly wetting the floor. We had a few cake crumbs that were stepped on so wouldn't come up with a broom, so we broke out the Swiffer...and nearly broke it trying to scrub the crumbs up. But again, it does smell very nice so if you are looking for a refill pack, I would recommend this one.