This fireplace door is well made and has a quality appearance and finish.  The color was a bit darker than the picture but none the less, beautiful.  The directions were a bit confusing to us, but we managed to get it installed after a few trys.  The only complaint I have is this, both the small and the medium size doors are the same width, even though the heights are different.  My fireplace width is 37 inches, (same as the small and medium).  It would have been nice if the medium were maybe 38 or 39 inches wide because you can see in from the sides a tiny bit and the large would have been overkill for my opening, hence, why not make the medium a bit wider?