These pillows seem comfortable and supportive after a few nights.  They are large and may not work if you need a lower profile.  We are not sure whether these are a better bet than the shredded foam, but they are made in the US and not extraordinarily overpriced like some recent trendy options.  SO far so good.  Not life changing - but for two people with very bad necks, so far , so good is praise!  Good value and probably will settle into be a good fit.