We haven't installed the pendants just yet, so my comments will be strictly on looks alone at this point.  One of the pendants does have a small ding on the top, but it's nothing that's going to be visible once it's installed and really not a big deal.  They look beautiful and just as we imagined they would.  Seemingly good quality and nothing less than expected.  Five stars on looks alone and I'll update my comments if there are any installation issues.