Spent the extra money to purchase this blanket because I wanted something that was all cotton and extremely soft.  This has the luxurious feel of a fleece blanket, but is 100% breathable cotton - the best of both worlds.  Gave it 4 stars because I felt it needed to be a little longer so that it could be tucked under the mattress.

Pros: all cotton, soft, great quality
Cons: pricey, a little short