The reason of 4 starts is that it looks pretty smart once built (with minimum instructions as we had to guess which shelf is which; no numbers on the shelf to identify). Could have been better quality wise as well as the front black drawer if not fixed 100% properly, will remain bit open. Looks good in the room overall, has no back so make sure the background is clean...the LED lights are a good innovation. I am happy with the purchase for the time being.