I just love the Carmack Server. It looks much more expensive than it was and adds drama and elegance to my living room. Although the box was a bit damaged, the packaging held up and all of the pieces were perfect. I had my handyman assemble it (mostly because many of the reviews that mentioned problems got me nervous about it) and he was able to do it himself in less than an hour (with no problems). He did mention that he's put together many Wayfair products and he thought this was one of the best constructed. My only negative is the crystal knobs. I thought it cheapened the look so I changed them to gold. 
Now I think it's perfect and even more than I had hoped for.