I got the 8' diameter round and am really happy with it.  The colors were perfect for my living area and very close to what you see in the picture.  The quality for the price is very good.  I had ordered another rug that didn't work out and it was really easy to return.  If you are curious the return shipping cost was very reasonable at ~$20.  I just went onto my account at Wayfair, filled out the form, printed a label and dropped the rug off at FedEx.  It was worth it to me to try both rugs to be sure I was getting the best colors and style for the area.