I really like the way this holder opens and closes. No spring action to deal with and doesn't have an open end like some other modern holders. I will say that the holder is quite large. It sticks out pretty far and is an inch or 2 wider than it needs to be to accommodate a standard toiler paper roll. This doesn't bother me, even in our small powder room, but it is a bit odd.

Pros: Seamless design
Cons: Larger than it needs to be