First of all, this bench has great style and size for a low price. However, I was mortified and my 215 lb male friend was embarrassed, when he sat down in the middle, alone, and the bench cracked. The long wooden piece in the front that connects both sides and upon which sits the seat slats has two large holes drilled for screws in the center which makes it weak there. Considering that this is a longer bench expected to hold 3 or 4 people, this front wooden support should be larger OR you could get lucky and have a skilled brother who will glue and screw long metal bars  behind each of the 3 benches you ordered (did I mention they look great) so you won't embarrass any more of your guests! The natural color will weather to grey and the black will turn a dark grey. I like a more rustic and casual look which plays well with colored cushions. Cushions always make your seating more comfortable but the bench is right sized even without them.