I would have rated this a 5 because I really love the overall size, appearance and function and it has good storage space, but it is not remotely durable. In less than one month, the top board warped and left a very noticeable ring after someone put a glass in the surface for only a few minutes, and now there is nothing to do about it to fix it. Such a bummer and very disappointed with that part. Wish I could fix it!