Looks exactly as it does online! Arrived without a scratch on the box, and was well packed regardless!
Super sturdy, very heavy, quality piece of furniture. The top is solid wood but does have a darker paint or stain and a heavy grain on the top. But I think it looks good. 
Legs are metals and spray painted to achieve the rustic look and can thus easily scratch, but you'd have to work pretty hard at it. Comes with rubber feet on the bottom to not scratch your floors (I put extra felt ones on because my floors scratch easily). 

The only two small details I can find were that hex bolts weren't white, they're silver, so you can see them if you look closely and there's a weird checkered pattern along the edge of the table top. Doesn't bother me enough to lessen the rating.

Great purchase! 

(stools also from Wayfair :)