2 of the chairs came defective.  We were able to fix one right away.  I called to report the other one broken but did not get a response.  Overall the chairs look nice but I dont expect them to hold up for more than 2-3 years.  They are smaller than I had imagined which is both good and bad.  Good Because I can fit 14 around my table.  Bad because I am afraid larger people will not be comfortable on the seat.