We ordered two of these rugs.  

Pros:
- Arrived quickly
- Look nice
- Soft for what it is

Cons:
- They are a little thinner than I would have liked but that's probably my fault for not checking more than the L x W. 
- There's an odor I've never experienced with rugs or carpet before.  I'm hopeful it will dissipate.
- The rugs themselves are straight, however, the pattern on them is a little off.  It's fine and adds to it.

So why 5 stars?  My wife picked these and I really like the look.  I wasn't sure I would but I do.  To me, they look old fashioned like I imagine something out of the 1920's would.  Then again, I don't really know what something out of the 1920's would like like but I like them so they get 5 stars.