We would give it a 5 for looks and what we wanted. 3 and a half or the materials used and 2 for the instructions.  Took longer than the 55 minutes suggested. Said many times to use the allen wrench when indeed you needed a screwdriver for one thing.
We were careful and followed the instructions. The drawers do not sit flush with the desk...Are they supposed to? we followed those directions closely also.  NOT going to take apart again to resemble.

Pros: Looks good.
Cons: A royal pain to put together.