I'd put this somewhere between 3 and 4 stars.  It looks great when put together.  It's not the sturdiest bed - the four legs are very small.  The dresser drawers don't fit well and require some fiddling to get them to slide smoothly in and out.  The bookcase is great.  The instructions were wrong in a couple places, but it was easy enough to visually look at the pieces and get them in the right spot.  My daughter loves it, though, so I guess that's what matters!