Love these chairs!  We've had them about 2-3 years now and they are holding up well.  They get daily use so I'd say that's good.  There is some grain that has been scratched here or there but all in all, good shape.  My only complaint has to do with the back of the chair - there is a nut and bolt in the middle of the "X".  My daughters hair catches in it and gets pulled out.  Also, the nut and bolt have unscrewed on multiple occasions and come out.  No biggie though.  Easy to put back.