I'd give it 4 stars looking at it from a distance.  Nice design.  The execution is a little cheap.  You'd expect the legs to be a solid piece, top to bottom.  They aren't.  They are several short pieces between the shelves and not sanded the best before finishing.  Because they are multiple pieces they don't follow a perfectly straight line and some have minor twists compared to the ones bellow.   If I was in a store I might have passed it for this reason.  Overall we are happy with it.

Other complaint, the description says it comes with a bulb but it doesn't.  I didn't expect one but please fix the description.