These are beautiful. There are many comments about the intentional brown spots that make them look dirty or weathered, its true, They are there. However, they're all in the corner of the design, so when I laid out my tiles I made sure to keep the 4 brown corners together, adds to the design. I gave a 2 star rating because in my box I received 7 damaged tiles. Luckily I didn't need all the tiles in the box, but frustrating since I had to pay for the whole box. Photos include a before picture with the ceramic tiles I put the vinyl over, two finish photos, and a photo of the damage to other tiles.