The first package I received was obviously someone's returned item, with the return slip stating damage, box was all mangled etc.  My wayfair associate remedied the situation fairly quickly and I got two brand new lamps, and was allowed to keep the defective pair.  I love the ones that do work but was a little shocked to get the weird return order at first!
The shades are a little thin and flimsy, might recommend replacement.  But the light is great and touch is awesome.  Love how little these are but how much soft light they produce!  

Pros: great amount of soft light, small nightstand friendly, comes in pair
Cons: came in damaged box with one damaged at first, flimsy paper shade