Super cool chair and unbelievably comfortable!!!  It came quickly and was pretty easy to assemble.  There were a few little scratches on the wood, but I don't think they are all that noticable.  Also, the armrests are just about a half an inch too high, in my opinion.  They get caught up under an average size desk so the material may end up getting pulled or torn so that is my only concern.  But, it looks great and it super comfy, so I'm giving it 4 !

Update:  After several months, we ended up taking the armrests off since they kept getting caught on the desk and were getting a bit torn!  We took the black bolts from the armrests and used them to cover the bolt holes on the body of the chair.  It still looks great:)