I think these chairs average out to 4 stars.  The appearance and quality look to be a 5.  The seat cushion is very well reinforced and it feels comfortable to sit in, but supportive.  The back is a little stiff given the tufting, but I imagine will soften some. Fabric is a nice linen cream color (though one chair did have some errant fluff interrupting the texture); the nail heads are large and oil rubbed bronze. The legs were listed as espresso, but I found them close to black in color.

The assembly was definitely a 3--there are only 10 bolts per chair/to screw in and it seems there was one hole on each chair for the seat which was presenting an alignment issue.  It took about 75 minutes for me to manage assembling them both, which seemed a little excessive given the simplicity.  I would recommend poking the bolts through all of the way on the seat and trying to get a line up on all of them before screwing too far.

Well packaged and quick arrival.  A solidly nice chair.