At first we really liked these stools they also shipped to us at lightening speed.  We bought two of the light brown, which is more of a pumpkin color.  I do question if they are real leather and look like vinyl.  As we have used these over the months we noticed that one of the stools does not seem stable at the base where the stool swivels.  We may be able to tighten this somehow but we'd have to remove the fabric bottom and see if that is possible.  We have four average-weight adults using these stools and they have minimal to normal wear.  They are not used daily.  Last night we saw chunks of black paint laying under one of the stools.  It was the lacquer/paint that just randomly fell off the inside leg of the stool in about a 4-5 inch area.  We are very disappointed in the quality of these stools.  They aren't exactly inexpensive. I'd really love to know how Wayfair can remedy the situation.