Maybe it's just personal preference, but this just isnt my go-to in the kitchen when taking cookies off the baking sheet (or other items from the baking sheet). If there's any amount of "stick to the sheet," then i reaxh for my metal Oxo turner, not a silicone one. The size of this one is, however, perfect for cookies, especially if theyre close together. Maybe my perfect tool would be a tiny metal one?