I knew from other reviews that this doesn't fully recess into the wall, but I got it anyway. I'm fairly happy with it, but I really, really wish it was more flat on the wall. I just went ahead and purchased it because it was the closest thing to what I needed. Have only had for about a week, but I think it will serve its purpose well in our newly renovated bathroom once we get it all primed, painted, and stocked with our belongings.