I gave this rug five stars because it deserves it for quality.  It is soft and thick and the colors coordinate perfectly with this rug which I had previously purchased for the dining room.  Since I ordered it in the 8x10, there is a large expanse of the rust color (website calls it red) in the center of the rug which I would not choose again;  but this is on me...and has nothing to do with the quality of the rug.   I do feel the website accurately reflects the colors.  As with this rug is a great value and very comparable with much more expensive rugs that I own. I also would like to commend this manufacturer for their customer service and for delivering items as promised.  Thank you!