Ive had two for several months.  The material is nice, the color a nice charcoal n and my dogs slobber wipes right off.  I love the style and the hammered nails. They hold a nice amount for storage including a neck massager,  throw blankets, ear phones.  I knocked off a star bc they are not perfectly shaped... the circle lid is wonky, and at one point a nail had fallen out.  But that only happened once.