I was in love with the navy version of these curtains but after about two years, I noticed sunlight coming through spots of one panel. The other side of it has the coating peeling off in about ten different spots all about the size of a dime or smaller. All the other 8 panels are fine so it must be some type of defect on this one. So I’d say a five on the other 8 but a 1 on this one panel. But the one panel being ruined also ruins the whole vibe.