Judging solely on the design, I would give it five stars. It’s the fabric that it’s made from that disappoints. It’s muslin-like (and low-grade muslin at that), and not durable at all. We owned it for all of two weeks before we had to repair an L shaped tear. Four months later and we now have as many holes in it, and all from normal use. It’ll be replaced soon with something that won’t look as good, but will last longer.