Very particular, did a lot of looking.  Am very happy with the quality of the stool.  Has some weight to it.  Wood grain is smooth enough and a medium tone -- it is more muted than I would prefer, so we will put a coat of poly on to bring out the grain and also to offer a bit of protection from spills.  NOTE:  the width is widest at the circular footrest!  The measurements list 15 wide, but that is the seat -- actual width is 18.5.  This makes for a much tighter fit for 4 at my island, but will JUST work and I like these enough to squeeze in a bit more.