So I got this because my current towel hanger was broken.  I received this and definitely agree that the packaging is really well done and all the material and instructions are there.  The items look nice and are relatively light weight.  My current towel hanger is much heavier metal, so I decided to repair it and just keep it.  Also, I personally I like the straight towel hanger more than the round.  In the end, 4 stars just because the material is so lightweight, where I normally would want something more “substantial” feeling.