This is absolutely beautiful and exceeded my expectations!  The only small blemish was a weird round white dot on the right end (on the side of the mantel so it doesn't show) which looks like a knot hole was filled but not stained after.  I may or may not try to "color it in" with a furniture marker, but like I said, it doesn't show so it doesn't bother me at all.  The mantel is gorgeous, and if you're on the fence (like I was), take the plunge and do it.  You will not be disappointed if this is the look you're going after.