this is a very nice looking chair. The reason for the 4 stars is the seat isn't as "comfy" as the sides but not uncomfortable. The sides of the chair are a little low.  It's also a little narrow for big hip people - (my hips 44) - if I continue eating I'm going to grow out of this chair) and one of the screws to screw in the legs was not usable (not sure if there is no screw in there?) but since each leg takes 3 screws leaving one out should not present a problem.  I am basically very happy with this chair.   Also you definately need padding under the legs and they will go right through your rug.