These chairs are very nice looking.  They were packaged well as not to chip the black coating on the legs.  However, they did chip very easily upon assembly. The chips are easy to hide so it is not a big deal, just be extra careful. The three stars come from wobble that we are getting with two of the stools and no way to adjust.  The width and depth of the seats are “comfortable enough”. I did not have any issue with seeing the black fabric up the back like other reviews have said.  All in all they are soft and very nice looking.