I needed smaller lamps for our living room, and these were perfect. 
I liked the design, matte black color, and height. I did have to “assemble” the lamp shade, which I didn’t realize when I ordered them. To put the shades together, you have a large hoop and a smaller hoop with Velcro, and you roll the shade (which also has Velcro) around them. It was not overly difficult, and I think they turned out well.