Ehh. These are oval and not round as I believed. They are also lightweight and less substantial than I would like. The shade requires assembly and the clips holding the shade to the wire frame was visible when the lamps are sitting on bedside table. They aren’t expensive but, in my opinion, they look cheaper than they are. (One of the shades arrived with a one inch red ink line in the middle. Wayfair was great about promptly handling the issue.)