I purchased three pieces from this set. I LOVE them! The shipping boxes were pretty beat up and one, the tape was partially gone. I was afraid they item had been damaged. I must say the packaging is meticulous! all the glass and chrome was well protected with layers of foam and hard plastic pieces to protect the packaging box from the inside. So even though the corners were dented or smashed the hard inner lining protected the item. There were a few small scratches on this item. It looked like the chrome layering had an issue. It is small and not noticeable so I chose to keep this item rather than exchange it