Meh. I bought two of these to cut down and use in one drawer. My husband cut them down and once they were in the drawer, I caulked the edges and the middle. It is functional for what I needed. I really like the idea of these inserts, and while I was satisfied with these two, the others I purchased for other drawers came scratched and didn't seem as study. I'm using those in the garage because it wasn't worth the hassle to return them.