We just remodeled the kitchen and I wanted a nice paper towel holder. Thinking about it now, the one with the spray in the middle may have been convenient since I cook all the time. I wouldn't have to open the cabinet to grab the cleaning products to clean the counter and it would be readily available. Anyways, I didn't purchase that one. This paper towel holder is great and does the job. The tension arm is sturdy and has held up well, especially during our parties. I'm happy with my purchase.