Wow! I purchased the 52"x52" papasan cushion and it is really nice! I probably could have gotten the 48" and been fine, but I figured a little too big would be better than too small so went with the bigger one. I was also stuck on which color to purchase because there weren't many customer photos for reference. I ended up choosing the Royal Blue cushion because I figured it was a safe choice; you really can't go wrong with blue and it turned out to be a beautiful shade! No regrets! The papasan cushion also shipped 8 days sooner than promised! I will definitely be purchasing more of these in the future! 

(Ps. If you purchase any of these cushions, please upload a photo or two! I'd love to see yours!)