I got these bar stools in gray. They were very well packed. Nothing was scratched. The assembly is generally simple. The only issue was lining up the holes. Sometimes it needed real force. This is the reason I gave 4 stars.  They look nice. The back fits under the bar top when swivels. I like the idea that they could be counter height as well as bar height.  Also, they feel sturdy.  I would recommend them.