It had a couple scratches on the edging that's a bummer, but they are small. I am a novice furniture assemblyperson and I built this completely solo (even though it says to have 2 people), so take my 4 out of 5 ranking with a grain of salt. But it was really difficult to get the base to align with the cabinets to screw in - I ultimately couldn't screw in a couple and had to accept defeat. But the final product works and looks great! Super proud of myself!