They are a nice size, but very rough around the edges of the openings. They are also not uniformly shiny in appearance. They are mostly shiny on the outside, but around the circular openings it looks as if someone took a scraping tool to them. They are not shiny on the inside. So overall they are not worth the price paid and I wouldn’t have bought them if I saw them in a store. That said, tucked away on the bottom of a bookshelf as long as you don’t pick them up they look ok.