I rate the product 5 stars, very nice dinnerware. Nicely made set and seems sturdy. The 1 star rating is for AllModern warehouse sending me the wrong product. I ordered the Red Robin set, but I received the Jay Blue set. Luckily I wasn't matching any theme that I have in place and I am only losing out on $.39 cents. It's not worth going through the trouble to get the color I initially wanted and ordered. Like anyone, it does frustrate me a bit though. I guess that's the risk we take ordering online sometimes. Hopefully this isn't something that happens often, but be aware it did happen to me.