These are fabulously comfortable and a great match to the set.  Only complaint is retaining water once they get wet.  We live in Florida and get pop up thunderstorms all summer long.  We found that if the cushions get wet they take A LONG TIME to dry out, especially with our humidity.  This is the reason for the four star and not five.  So for us we have had to keep the cushions off unless using.  In a dry climate this would not be a problem.  Over all very satisfied with the look and quality.