The actual shelf is nice and looks just like I thought it would. However, I've given a 3 rating because the box that it came in was nearly falling apart. By the time I brought it into my house I had styrofoam all over and the box with all the screws and nails in it was crushed and open. I had to go through and count all the pieces to ensure that nothing had fallen out in transit.  I'm not sure if this was the fault of the shipping company or how the product was stored in the warehouse but I was shocked at how disheveled the whole thing looked.