I love All-Clad pans, have several pieces and plan to purchase more. I wondered whether the D5 (5 layers) would be too heavy in comparison to the D3 (3 Layers). I purchased both and the difference is not noticeable. I think you can do well with the D3 if you're looking for a less costly version. It is just as amazing in the way it heats, cooks evenly and is easy to clean with Bon Ami. Or just wait until the D5 is on sale.