Overall quality of chairs is a 3. I ordered 4 chairs, one specifically has areas of poor factory painting, but I can touch up. These chairs will work nicely in our summer cottage. I would be hesitant to purchase these for daily use, that is why I rated a 3.  I will eventually stain the seats a darker stain to blend in with our décor. Overall, this product is as described. Instructions for assembly were easy to follow.