I'm giving this a 5 even though there was a thumb hole on the underside of the fabric.  (You cannot see it so I'm good and I got a discount) My decision is based on craftsmanship, quality and construction.  In addition, looking at the picture, I thought the color was off-white color but it's actually a light brown with beige.  For me, the color is perfect because it goes with the other brown tones I have in the room.  This sofa is spacious, well-built and the fabric will certainly hold up to wear and tear.  Worth every penny, I love it!