They are a beautiful matte black and are nice and heavy! I had an issue where a couple were nicked but they sent me replacements at no cost to me and very quickly.
-  Reasons I gave 3 stars: 
-- 1) the two ends of the handles are slightly different one, sticks out and is more beveled the other is flat. Its not terribly noticeable but I am super crazy about detail so I constantly notice it. It would be totally fine if you were using them only for doors (not pulls and doors like me).
-- 2) A couple of the pulls have silver spots near where its all connected underneath. Again not a huge deal BUT its making me a little nervous that they may chip one day. For now, they look beautiful and I am happy!!! Good thing is that Wayfair is awesome and so I am hopeful if anything were to happen that they would replace it!