I loved both of these products.  I recently got married, and I wanted a cedar chest for my                                                  wedding memories.  The lid does not lock right, because the holes were not pre-drilled.  Everything else was pre-drilled to make it easy to put together.  That was my only disappointment, but I will never lock it anyway.  I saved the key, but I really do not need it.  It is a beautiful cedar chest, much less expensive than a Lane brand, but the size is the same.  We are redecorating for Christmas, and I purchased the shower curtain in burgundy to match the cardinals in the shower curtain print that I bought.  It  will be beautiful for our guest bathroom.