I got this to try but ended up returning because I preferred the hanging caddy. I still liked this one a lot. My only complaints would be the shelves didn't seem quite level, so bottles would slide around pretty easily, and during assembly one of the rubber feet was almost impossible to get into the shaft, it was such a tight fit. But this is a great caddy. My mom has had this or a very similar one for 10+ years and hers is still going strong.