I gave this item a '4' only because my perception of it was that it would have been a bit thicker much like a kennel pad. With thatbsai the gray is pretty and very soft. I actually ordered it to protect the back seat of my car, which is where I tether my dog on road trips. However, I used it inside recently as my daughter was visiting with her dog and my grandpup sheds...a lot! It waz great as a comfy throw to protect the furniture.