I’d prefer to give a 1.5, because these would ultimately work if your only concern was blocking light (had your order not contained a piece with a puncture). These curtains have the texture of burlap. Everything about them is bulky. If the curtains are going to be this stiff, that should be advertised. You could probably stand them up on the floor delicately and it would take a bit for them to fall over. Not what I wanted, nor expected. They do not work well with double rods (ie, I wanted sheer panels behind these for daylight). One panel came with a puncture mark, which is a problem because I specifically need no light passing through.