Four stars- Wayfair purchase went smooth and shipping was decently fast.  The desk is of fairly good overall quality.  It is wood (with a visible wood grain), as opposed to particle board, easy to assemble, and the size was perfect for our spare bedroom.  However, it arrived with some small factory defects.  There is a finger-length spot where no wood finish was applied. The drawer was damaged on the inner side and missing several screws that held it together.  Overall, it was nothing I couldn't fix from my toolbox and a finish touch-up marker, so it wasn't worth the hassle to return.