We have only opened one stool out of 4.  The colors were great, quality is great, and the assembly was easy.  We are pleased with the size of the seat - very ample - bigger than our current stools.  The price was good for comparable products we have seen.  The look of the piece is great for a transitional kitchen - we are in the middle of remodel, hoping to maintain the casual, but somewhat industrial look.  
Very satisfied.  

Pros: Great value, good colors, good quality, easy assembly, meets description
Cons: No cons.