I am sad to give these only 3 stars because after all the work I really do like them. They arrived early which was a happy surprise! Though the boxes they came in were falling apart luckily they were not damaged but one was missing all the screws and nuts. The directions were there but nothing to put it together. So it cost extra to go to Lowe’s and find matching screws. On top of that the holes for the shelves and the metal frame didn’t match. So my husband had to drill the frame to make it fit. I would say that I love the after effect but, the work didn’t equal the cost. I really hope they hold up,but I am afraid they won’t. I would only recommend getting these if you are prepared to work for it and have power tools handily!